The winning Whitgift team, with trophy – Nic Gates, Richard Gibson, Martin Hayes, Nick Edwards, Jonny Ufton, Neill Williams
CYRIL GRAY 2024 – a tournament win for Whitgift
The Cyril Gray is a scratch foursomes competition played every year at Worplesdon, and contested by 32 of the 64 Halford Hewitt schools; it is limited to players over 50 years of age. There are three pairs per side, and the competition is a straight knockout, one school against another. Whitgift have won the Cyril Gray on two occasions, in 1974 and in 1999, twenty-five years apart, so those with an eye for symmetry were in eager anticipation of the 2024 event. The sense of expectation was increased by the prospect that captain Martin Hayes would be able to call on the services of three or four very capable golfers who have just turned 50, with all the advantages that brings in terms of relative fitness and strength.
Day 1

A week that was generally sunny began with a first-round tie against Ampleforth, on tournament Wednesday.
The team for round 1 was (photo, back row) Jonny Ufton, Richard Gibson, Mark Haswell, (front row) Nick Edwards, Martin Hayes, Alan Scovell. Gibson & Edwards led the way and were never in serious trouble, beating their opponents 5&4, and so the overall win depended on one of the other pairs. Hayes & Haswell, playing second pair, were generally ahead through their round, initiated by a superb approach on the 1st from the left hand rough to about six feet from the pin, by Haswell – but it got close on one or two occasions, whilst the third pair (Ufton & Scovell) fell away on the back nine. So, an eventual 3&2 win for Hayes & Haswell was welcome, and the 2-1 win qualified the team for the introduction of Neill Williams, so successful the previous year, and the experienced Nic Gates, who were available for the following rounds.
Day 2
Fettes were the next opponents, a school with six tournament wins and a 7-2 playing record against Whitgift. Former captain Tony Mason has especially fond memories of them (Fettes beat Whitgift in the 2014 final). The suspicion early on was that Fettes, perhaps with knowledge of Neill’s arrival, had played the ‘undercut’, by putting their weakest pair out first against Hayes & Williams (photo).

Whether or not that is the case, Hayes & Williams cruised to a 9&7 win, and whilst the two matches further back were closer, Whitgift emerged overall winners by 2 ½ – ½, with a 4&3 win for Gibson & Edwards, and a half declared in the other match when the overall result was decided.
The going got significantly tougher in the afternoon, against more, and still familiar, Scottish opposition in the form of Watson’s, who also held an historical edge against Whitgift, this time by 5-3. Martin Hayes himself decided on a change of order for this match, playing Gates & Ufton as second pair, with Gibson & Edwards playing third. Despite stepping up against strong opposition, Gates & Ufton were always in the match, and after six holes, Whitgift were ahead, albeit narrowly, in all three matches. Then, shock horror, around the turn Watson’s nudged themselves ahead against Hayes & Williams, whilst at the rear, Gibson & Edwards were showing their superiority, pulling 4up after 13 holes. The middle match started to look key, and Gates & Ufton were hanging in, still 1 up after 12. The cut and thrust continued down the stretch, certainly in those top two matches, and both matches completed the 16th hole at evens. With the third match now won, in the top match Whitgift found themselves needing to hole a knee-trembling five-footer for par on 17 to stay level, but Hayes rose to the challenge, and frayed nerves (mine anyway) headed towards the 18th hole, with the two remaining matches still level. This could go either way.
Hayes sent his drive on the last about 290 yards down the middle of the fairway, whilst his Watson’s opponent was probably about 50 yards further back. Watson’s approach was to the left-hand side of the green and toppled over the bank into quite a deep swale, whilst Neill Williams, ever the calm executioner, delivered a 150-yard wedge to within four feet of the hole. Watson’s failed to make par and conceded the match, thus giving Whitgift a semi-final berth.
Such is the delicacy of these matters, with handshakes exchanged but little in the way of backslapping, that Whitgift’s celebrations failed to convey themselves to the match following, and so neither Gates nor Ufton knew that the overall result was decided, and neither did their Watson’s opponents. Clearly both would have seen that the top match had concluded, but with what score?! So, imagine the relief of both Whitgiftians, and the dismay of the Watson’s pair, when Watson’s won the hole – and everybody watching just shrugged their shoulders. It’s probably fair to say – and understandable – that both pairs were annoyed with their fellow team members and supporters! Hayes put it down to his desire to sharpen their match practice, unaffected by knowing the result up top!
A 2-1 win for Whitgift, in what proved to be the closest tie of Whitgift’s tournament.
Day 3
The final day dawned, with the good weather still on offer, plus a semi-final against local rivals Epsom, who had beaten Glenalmond, Eastbourne and Blundells en route. Epsom and Whitgift players generally know each other quite well, because they often play practice matches against one another, and a great many of them are fellow club members at Walton Heath. And on this occasion, whilst Whitgift reverted to order of strength in their pairings, Epsom appeared to flip their order, with the strongest going last. Match 3 was going to be tricky.
It was. Try as they might, Gates & Ufton never really got into the game, were six down after twelve holes, and lost soon after. However, the top two pairs took things in their stride and both emerged as fairly comfortable winners, with everything over by the 15th hole, leaving time spare in the morning to catch up with the Seniors competition where Tony Mason and Peter Blok were representing Whitgift (you need two players with a combined age of 140 for this one) over one round of scratch stableford. Tony and Peter grew into the round and finished with 25 points, good enough for third place behind Canford and King’s Canterbury.
One team without any time to spare, however, were Chigwell, who were battling Merchiston for the remaining place in the final. Playing in the second semi-final is always hard because you are at least half an hour behind the first semi, and have to play catch-up over the lunch break, with little time for even a sandwich. This is compounded if, as in Chigwell’s case, your match goes to extra holes; one of their number was seen stuffing a sandwich into his bag for the final. Meanwhile, Whitgift had a fairly relaxing lunch ……
Miracle of the Macon

Domaine de Rochebin Macon Villages 2022 is described as “Deliciously light in body, vivaciously fresh and clean. Peach stone fruits, pear, apple and melon with a hint of cream oak and nuttiness. Refreshing, balancing acidity with lovely light minerals.” Empirical analysis suggests it is also good for your golf.
Certainly Gates & Ufton, soundly beaten in the morning, emerged stunningly fortified in the afternoon, playing in the third pair with a refreshed freedom and confidence. A rifled iron into the fourth green by Gates set up Ufton for an 8-foot birdie two and set the tone for the front nine, from which they extracted a 3-up lead.
The top two matches were much closer affairs and fluctuated either way, and therefore the balance of the entire final fluctuated in turn. Hayes & Williams made a relatively slow start and were 1 down in the early stages, but made a strong recovery on the 13th and 14th, eventually winning on the 16th after their opponents hit a wide tee shot. Gibson & Edwards, on the other hand – apparently playing Chigwell’s strongest pairing – lost a hard-earned lead on the 12th when driving out of bounds, and could not recover, going to the 17th tee two down. By this stage, all attention was back on the third match, which reached the 15th green with Gates & Ufton still 3 up, but with Gates marginally wide with a 15-foot effort from the side of the green to win the hole and the match. 3up with 3 to play, and a crowd of people around the par 3 16th green, including the Cyril Gray President in a buggy holding an inviting glass of wine – was it the de Rochebin? Gates hit an iron about 25 foot past the pin, straight but all downhill from there. Chigwell were closer, so Jonny Ufton had to putt
first, hitting a finely judged putt which was never moving fast but still managed to trickle past the hole, leaving his partner with a 3-foot putt, but importantly, uphill. Chigwell just failed with their effort from about 15 feet, leaving Nic Gates with the opportunity to make the winning putt. Which he duly took (photo).
The official result appears to have been 2 ½ – ½, which implies that Gates’ winning putt was holed before Whitgift were beaten 2&1 in the second pair, but Gates & Edwards appeared to accept that they had lost. And who would begrudge Chigwell, who had fought so hard in their first ever final? And without the chance to indulge at lunchtime!
Congratulations to all who played, including Messrs Haswell and Scovell in round 1. Martin Hayes emerged from the week with five points out of 5, followed by Neill Williams 4 out of 4, and Richard Gibson and Nick Edwards, both 4 out of 5. Nic Gates and Jonny Ufton won the deciding match and are seeking sponsorship from de Rochebin.
Drink responsibly.